SINGAPORE, 19 November 2026 – As governments introduce age restrictions on social media, researchers from Singapore Management University (SMU), the University of Oxford, Harvard University and other institutions argued that protecting young people also requires attention to how they develop the skills and judgement needed to participate safely online.
Published recently in The Lancet Child & Adolescent Health, the academic commentary titled Digital readiness, not age: youth social media policy needs a developmental approach proposes a framework combining baseline safety protections, graduated access to higher-risk features, continuing digital education and ongoing policy review.
Zhang Qiyang (张起阳), Assistant Professor in Communication and Technology from SMU’s College of Integrative Studies, the academic commentary’s first author, worked with her co-authors: Cameron Tan, PhD student from the Department of Social Policy and Intervention at the University of Oxford; Yueyin Ni, third-year undergraduate student from the University of California, Los Angeles; Laura Marciano, Assistant Professor at the Media School, Indiana University Bloomington, and an associate at Boston Children’s Hospital’s Digital Wellness Lab; and Dr Zhiying Yue, Scientist at the Digital Wellness Lab at Boston Children’s Hospital, who is also a research fellow at Harvard Medical School.
The researchers recognised that age thresholds can provide clear rules, help families coordinate around shared expectations and place enforcement responsibility on platforms. However, circumvention, migration to less-regulated services and privacy risks associated with age verification mean that age restrictions cannot carry the entire regulatory burden.
“Age thresholds provide a clear rule, but readiness develops at different rates. Young people also need support to build their judgement and safeguards that make social media safer,” said Assistant Prof Zhang.
Why age alone does not determine digital readiness
The researchers highlighted three capacities that support safe participation in social media: self-regulation to disengage from endless feeds, resilience to withstand social comparison, and risk appraisal to assess unsolicited contact and manage personal disclosure.
These capacities mature on different timetables. Sensitivity to peer evaluation peaks in early adolescence, while associations between social media use and wellbeing vary by age and sex. Research can hardly identify a precise developmental age at which every young person is ready to use these capacities appropriately.
While a single age threshold is administratively clear, young people still need preparation and safeguards that reflect the demands of different online activities.
A developmental approach to social media safety
To explain how this could work, the researchers referenced the graduated driver licensing system, a multi-stage process that allows novice drivers to gain road experience gradually rather than receiving full, unrestricted driving privileges all at once. This approach had been shown to reduce crashes among young drivers without prohibiting driving.
Applied to social media, a developmental approach would match safeguards to the foreseeable risks of different platform functions. Algorithmic feeds, livestreaming, direct messages from unknown adults and appearance-altering filters would be assessed according to the risks they pose, with proportionate protections required.
The academic commentary stressed that digital education cannot compensate for unsafe design. Supporting young people’s ability to make informed choices must therefore go hand in hand with enforceable responsibilities for platforms.
Recommendations for policymakers
Building on its framework, the academic commentary outlined four complementary measures to help young people navigate social media safely:
1. Establish baseline safety protections for all minors
Platforms should provide safer defaults, including private accounts for minors, safeguards against unsolicited contact from unknown adults, and engagement-extending features such as autoplay and streaks switched off. Recommender systems should be barred from exploiting behavioural signals. These duties should be independently overseen and legally enforceable.
2. Introduce graduated access to higher-risk features
Regulators, advised by developmental scientists, should assess platform functions according to their foreseeable risks and require proportionate safeguards. Age verification should also meet strict data-minimisation standards and protect users’ privacy.
3. Begin digital education and support early
Governments should fund research-based programmes developed with young people and delivered through schools, health services and community organisations, with additional support for under-resourced settings. Platforms should also provide practical support, including time cues, reflection prompts and warnings about potentially risky actions.
4. Build regular review into legislation
Age-based laws should include scheduled reviews, with outcomes such as mental health and sleep specified in advance. Independent researchers should have access to relevant platform data to assess whether policies are working and identify unintended consequences, allowing regulation to adapt as evidence develops.
Supporting young people beyond the age threshold
The researchers identified a role for paediatricians, school health services and child mental health professionals in translating the framework into practice.
Guidance should address how social media use may displace sleep, physical activity and in-person interaction, alongside risks such as online victimisation, compulsive use and sexual coercion. Clinicians can identify young people who need additional support, regardless of age.
The researchers also called on professional bodies to communicate evidence and uncertainty, advocate transparent and enforceable policies, and ensure that young people help shape regulatory decisions.
To access the full academic commentary, please click here.